[IP] anti-Goodmail coalition resorts to misquotes
Begin forwarded message:
From: Esther Dyson <edyson@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: March 20, 2006 11:03:37 AM EST
To: dave@xxxxxxxxxx
Cc: Christina Koukkos <christina@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: anti-Goodmail coalition resorts to misquotes
For the record, I said that *sending* most mail will cost money, and
that much of that money will end up being paid to the recipients.
Read below and then follow the link to the NYT to see what I *really*
said.
I find it ironic that many of the very people who want to teach
evolution in the schools (a position I agree with it), want to stop
it on the Internet.
Esther Dyson
From: "Trevor FitzGibbon" <tfitzgibbon@xxxxxxxxxx>
To: <edyson@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Dyson Blows AOL's Cover on E-Tax
Sender: "Trevor FitzGibbon" <tfitzgibbon@xxxxxxxxxx>
DearAOL.com Coalition
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: CONTACT: Trevor Fitzgibbon, 202-246-5303
Monday, March 20, 2006 Alex Howe, Fenton Communications, 202.822.5200
In New York Times, AOL email tax supporter says
it’s “only right” that in future “most e-mail will cost money”
AOL’s claim that consumers will ultimately pay “Nothing. Zero.
Nada.”
is debunked by prominent fan of AOL plan
DearAOL.com Coalition’s “two-tiered Internet” warning is vindicated
by Esther Dyson
On Friday’s New York Times op-ed page, AOL email tax supporter
Esther Dyson revealed the truth: AOL’s proposed email tax will lead
to a world where sending email is no longer free -- and she likes
it that way.
“Today, AOL’s own supporter let the cat out of the bag,” said
Timothy Karr, campaign director of Free Press, a national,
nonpartisan organization working on media reform and Internet
policy issues. “AOL’s email tax undermines the foundation of a free
and open Internet – ushering in a new era of pay-to-send
communications online. Many who are rooting for AOL’s pay-to-send
proposal to succeed are those who believe in a two-tiered Internet
of haves and have-nots, with huge barriers of entry for the little
guy.”
Dyson is an industry insider, an investor in technology start-ups,
and a former board member of the Electronic Frontier Foundation (a
DearAOL.com coalition member). Her New York Times column Friday was
called “You’ve Got Goodmail.” Goodmail is the vendor that would
implement AOL’s pay-to-send proposal, and would share hundreds of
millions in profits with AOL from the email tax.
Dyson wrote:
“Goodmail has been met with a barrage of criticism and calls for a
de facto boycott from several nonprofit and public interest groups.
These organizations seem to think that all Internet mail must
always be free, just because it was free before. …Of course, the
critics say, this is the first step. Pretty soon all mail will cost
money, and then the free, open world of the Internet will be closed
to poor people, nonprofits and other good guys, while multinational
conglomerates fill their ever-growing pockets. I agree that pretty
soon sending most e-mail will cost money, but I think that's only
right.” (<http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/17/opinion/
17dyson.html>http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/17/opinion/17dyson.html )
Dyson’s acknowledgement undermines AOL’s PR scheme for its pay-to-
send proposal, which centers on convincing the public that their
email tax is “voluntary” and “nothing will change” for everyday
emailers.
AOL recently emailed customers who were concerned about their email
tax proposal, saying Goodmail is “a purely voluntary” option for
“large commercial companies and other organizations” and “in no way
means that mailers need to pay to send messages.” Additionally, AOL
went so far as to say that after their email tax is implemented,
ultimately “Consumers pay nothing. Zero. Nada.” (Source: <http://
www.nysun.com/article/28345?page_no=2>http://www.nysun.com/article/
28345?page_no=2)
The Silicon Valley-based San Jose Mercury News initially dealt a
blow to this claim with a March 5 editorial saying “separate,
unequal systems” would develop from AOL’s email tax. It explained,
“The temptation would be to neglect the free e-mail system, whose
reliability would decline. Eventually, everyone would migrate to
the fee-based system. There would be no way around the AOL
tollbooth.” (<http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/
opinion/14023726.htm>http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/
news/opinion/14023726.htm )
On Friday, AOL’s assurances were again called into question – this
time by AOL’s own supporter, Dyson, who said that AOL’s pay-to-send
scheme is a significant step toward a world where “most e-mail will
cost money” – which she calls “only right.”
"Esther Dyson apparently believes that email being free is a
problem, but the DearAOL.com Coalition believes free email has been
a critical part of the digital revolution -- the ability to take a
good idea and spread it from 5 to 5 million people without a big
bankroll has expanded democratic
participation, increased economic innovation, and bolstered free
speech," said Cindy Cohn, Legal Director of the Electronic
Frontier Foundation.
The DearAOL.com Coalition represents over 15 million people
combined – and has grown from 50 member organizations to 600 in
less than three weeks. It’s “Open Letter To AOL” opposing AOL’s
email tax has been signed by over 35,000 everyday Internet users
online. Coalition members include Craigslist founder Craig Newmark,
the Association of Cancer Online Resources, MoveOn.org Civic
Action, Gun Owners of America, the Electronic Frontier Foundation,
Free Press, and others.
More information about the DearAOL.com Coalition and a list of all
coalition members are located at <http://www.dearaol.com/
>www.dearaol.com.
###
Esther Dyson Always make new mistakes!
Editor, Release 1.0
CNET Networks
20th floor - last elevator
104 Fifth Avenue (at 16th Street)
New York, NY 10011 USA
+1 (212) 924-8800
Flight School, Aspen, June 15-16 at http://www.release1-0.com/events
current status (with pictures!) at http://www.flickr.com/photos/edyson/
book: Release 2.0 (Broadway Books)
-------------------------------------
You are subscribed as roessler@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To manage your subscription, go to
http://v2.listbox.com/member/?listname=ip
Archives at: http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/