[IP] Today's Yahoo Appellate Decision
Begin forwarded message:
From: Joel Reidenberg <reidenberg@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: January 12, 2006 5:13:48 PM EST
To: dave@xxxxxxxxxx
Cc: ip@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Today's Yahoo Appellate Decision
Dave,
In the latest skirmish in the legal battle between the French and US
courts over Yahoo's display of Nazi memorabilia to French Internet
surfers, the US federal appeals court reversed and dismissed Yahoo's
earlier declaratory judgment against the enforceability of the French
order in the US. (http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/ca9/newopinions.nsf/
3DF703F416DC0608882570F40006DDCF/$file/0117424.pdf?openelement)
Yahoo lost its US action on technical legal grounds-- 3 judges said
the US court had no personal jurisdiction over the French defendants
and 3 judges said that Yahoo was pre-mature in bringing the action to
a US court because Yahoo. Thus, there was a majority to reverse and
dismiss. There was no majority on the 1st Amendment issue so that
question remains open.
Nevertheless, there was a majority on personal jurisdiction that held
the French parties were subject to suit in the US on the basis of
three contacts-- a cease and desist letter sent to California,
service of process for the French proceeding in the US, and service
of the French court order in the US. The latter-- service of the
French order-- was the main contact for the court. This is a
radical and troubling expansion of US jurisdiction that may put US
companies at risk abroad. In essence, the majority would allow any
US company that loses a law suit abroad to bring the suit back to the
US for a second bite at the apple. Foreign courts considering
comity will now feel justified in doing the same thing to US
companies who sue foreignors in the US-- ie make US companies defend
a favorable American court judgment against the foreignor in the
foreignor's home forum.
By the way, the court did take note of the mis-translation of the
French opinion that was first identified in my article, "Technology
and Internet Jurisdiction," 153 Univ. of Penn. L. Rev. 1951 (2005)
http://ssrn.com/abstract=691501
Regards,
Joel
******************************************** Joel R. Reidenberg
Professor of Law Fordham University School of Law 140 West 62nd
Street New York, NY 10023 Tel: 212-636-6843 Fax: 212-636-6899 Email:
<reidenberg@xxxxxxxxxxx> Web page: <http://
reidenberg.home.sprynet.com>
********************************************
-------------------------------------
You are subscribed as roessler@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To manage your subscription, go to
http://v2.listbox.com/member/?listname=ip
Archives at: http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/