[IP] California panel urges e-voting overhaul
Delivered-To: dfarber+@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Date: Wed, 28 Apr 2004 22:16:46 -0400 (EDT)
From: sob@xxxxxxxxxxx (Scott Bradner)
Subject: California panel urges e-voting overhaul
To: dave@xxxxxxxxxx
http://news.com.com/2100-1028_3-5201845.html?tag=nefd.top
California panel urges e-voting overhaul
Last modified: April 28, 2004, 6:55 PM PDT
By <http://news.com.com//2040-1096_3-0.html?tag=byline>Reuters
<http://news.com.com//2102-1028_3-5201845.html?tag=st.util.print>
Print story
<http://news.com.com//2113-1028_3-5201845.html?tag=st.util.email>
E-mail story
<http://news.com.com/#yourtake>
Your take
<http://news.com.com/javascript:void(0)>
[]
SACRAMENTO, Calif.--Electronic voting systems should not be used in
November's presidential election unless they produce a paper trail as a
safeguard against vote tampering, a California panel said Wednesday.
The advisory panel also urged California officials to require manufacturers
of the systems to upgrade security measures to prevent hackers from
tampering with votes. The motion specifically recommends new electronic
voting machines be required to print paper-based vote records that voters
could use to verify that their ballots had been cast as intended.
The motion comes amid a national debate about the use of electronic voting
machines, which had been put forward as a way to avoid the kinds of
punch-card irregularities that dogged the last presidential vote in Florida.
"Paper is coming to California," said John Mott-Smith, a member of the
California Voting Systems and Procedures Panel. "It's not a question of if,
but a question of when."
Seven members of the eight-member advisory panel backed the motion and one
abstained. The vote followed hearings over the past two weeks in which
activists, including president of the California Voter Foundation, demanded
paper-based proof of votes.
By contrast, elections officials from a number of California counties
warned they would have to scramble to prepare for the November election if
electronic voting were scrapped altogether, as some had urged.
The California panel has been closely watched because many of the high-tech
state's counties have scrapped punch-cards in favor of electronic voting,
which holds the promise of more efficient elections.
Voting on the systems in March in some California counties, however, was
marred by a number of glitches.
A report by the secretary of state found that 55 percent of polling places
in San Diego County were unable to open on time because a component on a
system did not function properly. Some polling places in Alameda County
experienced the same problem but had paper ballots on hand for voters.
For the March election, California counties fielded 42,720 electronic
voting machines, in theory allowing 42 percent of the state's voters to
vote on touch screens or on paper ballots scanned into computers.
In addition to its recommendation for new electronic voting machines, the
panel said existing machines other than those supplied by a subsidiary of
Diebold also should be required to print a paper trail of votes, or
counties with the machines must offer voters paper ballots.
The panel voted last week to recommend that California counties
<http://news.com.com//2100-1028-5197870.html?tag=nl>not use Diebold
Election Systems machines after finding they failed to work as expected in
the March election.
The panel recommended that California Secretary of State Kevin Shelley
decertify the subsidiary's AcuVote-TSx Voting System for use in California
and recommended its findings should be referred to the state's attorney
general for possible civil and criminal charges.
An aide to Shelley, who since last year has urged that touchscreen machines
produce paper records of votes, said the secretary of state could act on
the panel's recommendations by the end of the week.
-------------------------------------
You are subscribed as roessler@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To manage your subscription, go to
http://v2.listbox.com/member/?listname=ip
Archives at: http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/