If you have a 20,000 bot botnet and each bot has 2 defined recursive dnsservers that it is allowed to use and these bots are on the local subnet (ieBCP38 is implimented at the gateway but not at every router) then howexactly is locking down recursive servers so you can only use yours going tosolve anything?
uh... caching maybe?... the second field of your answer section when using dig..
To fix DNS we would have to eliminate it's use of UDP which means pretty much all internet software would need to be rewritten, that is an unrealistic goal.
no, its not, and it doesnt require that all internet sofware be rewritten, it means that they either need to be recompiled, or just have the dynamicly linked library they use for dns resolution to be replaced..
Locking down recursive servers may increase the number of machines required to create a flood but again a large botnet will have no problem so that's no solution either. BCP38 will accomplish the same ineffective goal but at least has the added potential to reduce non DNSrelated spoofed attacks at the same time making it easier to at least trackdown the sources of a distributed flood at least to the provider level if not to the exact IP.
i think its pretty obvious that locking down dns servers at least brings the DNS attacks down to the same problem weve always had.. that being good old fashioned udp packeting. and at that point.. why bother using dns..
-phar